Home Photography Which Editing Program Is Best? (2021)

Which Editing Program Is Best? (2021)

by kyngsam


Unsure whether or not to make use of Capture One or Lightroom to your picture enhancing? Each applications have loads of followers, however which choice is greatest for you?

This text goals to provide you a transparent, unbiased evaluation of the professionals and cons of Seize One vs Lightroom. By the point you’re finished, you’ll know all about these two applications – and also you’ll know which one is correct to your wants.

Let’s get began.

Seize One overview

capture one vs lightroom

Due to its superior instruments, Capture One is usually the selection {of professional} photographers and retouchers. It’s a high-end program that provides highly effective tethered shooting, in-depth picture enhancing, and a strong image-organization system that’ll fulfill even essentially the most demanding of photographers.

Professionals

  • An unlimited vary of image-editing instruments and options
  • Tethered taking pictures choice that performs effectively
  • Designed for skilled workflows
  • Superior RAW picture processing

Cons

  • The person interface may be complicated – it’s not all the time straightforward to search out the instruments you want
  • Not beginner-friendly
  • Costly
  • Picture group/library function is clunky and troublesome to make use of
  • No easy one-click presets or filters

Lightroom overview

Lightroom Develop module interface

Lightroom affords picture group and library options, in addition to RAW, TIFF, and JPEG image processing. Due to Lightroom’s easy integration with Adobe Photoshop, many photographers use each applications for picture enhancing. Lightroom is straightforward to make use of and features a vary of one-click presets to hurry up your workflow.

Professionals

  • Simple for learners to make use of
  • Easy and efficient picture library/group
  • Good vary of one-click presets out there on-line
  • Good for learners and superior photographers
  • Reasonably priced

Cons

  • No picture adjustment layers
  • Subscription-only mannequin
  • Tethered taking pictures performs poorly
  • Picture enhancing instruments not as superior as Seize One

Seize One vs Lightroom: in-depth comparability

Now that you just’re broadly conversant in these two applications, let’s take a more in-depth take a look at how they stack up, beginning with:

Modifying instruments

Whereas each Seize One and Lightroom provide a near-identical vary of fundamental picture enhancing instruments, there are some key variations price contemplating.

First, Seize One affords adjustment layers, whereas Lightroom doesn’t.

Capture One adjustment layers
Adjustment layers in Seize One.

Lightroom is designed for use alongside Adobe Photoshop, a complicated layer-based editor. So if you wish to use adjustment layers, you do have the choice to ship your Lightroom-adjusted recordsdata throughout to Photoshop, although this may be inconvenient in comparison with Seize One’s extra complete, one-stop-shop strategy.

Each applications provide lens corrections and profiles, in addition to the standard cropping and rotating options, and so on. As a fast apart, the Crop instrument in Lightroom is less complicated to make use of than the one in Seize One – and it’s additionally far simpler to search out!

The Lightroom Crop tool
Crop instrument in Lightroom.

Seize One and Lightroom can course of RAW recordsdata, however Seize One does have the sting right here, particularly contemplating the quantity of fine-tuning you are able to do with the shadows and highlights. Seize One affords excessive dynamic vary enhancing of your RAW recordsdata, which helps you to make vital changes to the highlights, shadows, blacks, and whites:

Capture One Exposure and High Dynamic Range tools
Excessive Dynamic Vary instrument in Seize One.

Whereas Lightroom affords RAW publicity changes of its personal, the choices are clunkier and fewer refined in comparison with Seize One.

What’s one space the place Seize One actually beats Lightroom palms down? Colour changes. The Seize One Colour Editor doesn’t simply provide Primary and Superior choices, but additionally a instrument to fine-tune pores and skin tones, plus an excellent interface that severe colour editors will love.

Capture One color edits
Colour Editor in Seize One.

Seize One additionally affords the Colour Stability instrument with Grasp, 3-Method, Shadow, and Spotlight choices. If colour grading is your factor, Seize One blows Lightroom out of the water; its refined instruments are able to performing even essentially the most demanding of colour edits.

Capture One Color Balance tool for color grading
Colour Stability instrument in Seize One.

Lightroom does provide colour changes, in fact, however nothing similar to Seize One:

Lightroom HSL panel
HSL panel in Lightroom.

Tethered taking pictures can also be the place Seize One excels. I’ve used it extensively, and it’s quick and environment friendly. Though Lightroom does provide tethering, it’s not dependable, and it’s sluggish and glitchy at occasions. It simply doesn’t minimize the mustard for a professional photographer, particularly one who has shoppers ready to see the RAW photographs throughout an in-progress session.

Ease of Use

So far as I’m thought-about, Lightroom is far simpler to make use of; the interface is straightforward, and you’ll view all of the instruments and options on one display. 

Seize One, then again, makes use of a sequence of tabs, cursor instruments, menus, and sub-menus, and it’s straightforward to get misplaced or spend ages looking for one thing you want.

The Lightroom Library system can also be clear and easy, whereas Seize One makes this unnecessarily sophisticated. 

Organizing images in Lightroom
The Lightroom Library.

Utilizing presets in Lightroom is straightforward. Obtain your presets, import them into Lightroom, and so they’ll seem on the lefthand facet of the Develop module. Hover your mouse over a preset to see the way it will have an effect on your picture, click on to pick a favourite, and also you’re finished. Simply take a look at the simplicity of Lightroom’s Preset panel:

Lightroom presets

Seize One doesn’t do presets – kind of. It does have preset equivalents, however they’re referred to as Types, and also you’ll have to enter the Changes tab and comply with the sub-menu to search out and apply them:

Capture One Styles

Additionally, Types packs are costly, whereas there are many free Lightroom presets available on the market.

Supported file codecs

Seize One helps the next file codecs:

  • RAW
  • DNG
  • JPEG
  • TIFF
  • PNG
  • PSD (read-only)
  • HEIF/HEIC
  • DNG recordsdata are supported in Seize One Professional, however not in model variations (e.g., Seize One for Fujifilm, Seize One for Sony, and so on.)

Lightroom helps these file codecs:

  • RAW
  • Digital Unfavorable format (DNG)
  • HEIF/HEIC
  • TIFF 
  • JPEG 
  • Photoshop format (PSD)
  • Giant Doc format (PSB)
  • CMYK recordsdata
  • AVI
  • MP4
  • MOV
  • AVCHD

If you wish to use PSD or PSB codecs, then Lightroom can be your best option. It’s additionally greatest for individuals who wish to import the supported video recordsdata listed right here. As famous with Seize One, DNG recordsdata from all cameras are solely supported within the Professional model, whereas all DNG recordsdata are supported in Lightroom, no matter which digicam they got here from.

Is there a cellular model?

Lightroom affords a totally free app to your system, downloadable from each iOS and Android app shops. You will want an Adobe subscription to entry a number of superior options, however when you’ve bought Lightroom, this may handle itself. Additionally, observe that photographs and edits out of your Lightroom app will sync throughout your Lightroom CC applications – so you may edit in your telephone, then see the adjustments in your desktop (and vice versa).

Sadly, Seize One doesn’t at present provide any type of cellular app. If you wish to edit photographs taken in your smartphone, you’ll must switch them to your laptop (and if you wish to edit photographs in your telephone, you’re out of luck, although you may all the time seize the free Lightroom app).

Pricing

As with all Adobe apps, Lightroom is just out there as a month-to-month subscription. You should buy Lightroom CC by itself – with 1 TB of cloud storage – for $9.99 USD monthly, or you may seize Lightroom as a part of Adobe’s Inventive Cloud Photography Plan, which incorporates entry to Lightroom CC, Lightroom Basic, and Photoshop CC and begins at $9.99 USD monthly, although you may pay further for extra cloud storage.

Sadly, Capture One is kind of costly, and the pricing construction may be complicated, too. You should purchase this system outright or hire it by way of a month-to-month subscription, and you should buy plans for particular digicam manufacturers, resembling Sony, Fujifilm, or Nikon (these camera-specific plans are cheaper, however can solely be used on photographs from sure cameras).

Seize One Professional is $299 USD for a brand new perpetual license, and subscription plans begin at $19 USD monthly. An annual pay as you go subscription for Seize One for Fujifilm, Nikon, or Sony is $149 USD (which involves round $12.50 USD monthly).

Seize One vs Lightroom: closing ideas

Finally, the software program you select can be a mirrored image of your preferences, your talent degree, and your price range.

Due to this fact, in case you are an expert photographer who requires an built-in workflow from tethered taking pictures by to completed photographs, then Seize One is the only option. It’s additionally this system to decide on when you like superior enhancing and colour grading on adjustment layers. 

Lightroom, then again, is nice for learners, intermediate, and professional photographers who don’t want the large array of options and instruments out there in Seize One. Lightroom can also be cheaper, plus it’s extra nice to make use of.

I’ve used each applications extensively, and every has its personal sturdy and weak factors. For those who’re nonetheless on the fence, I’d suggest you’re taking the time to find out the options which can be essential to you in a picture editor. That means, you may make an knowledgeable choice concerning the most effective program to your enhancing wants.

Now over to you:

Which program do you want higher, Lightroom or Seize One? Which do you intend to buy? Share your ideas within the feedback beneath!





Source link

Related Articles

Leave a Comment